How to Select a Cheap ATS Without Sacrificing Quality

Recruiting can be costly, and for small agencies, growing companies, and startups, working within a limited budget is often necessary. This guide explains how affordable applicant tracking systems (ATS) can help support an efficient hiring process without requiring a large financial investment. The aim is not only to find low-priced tools, but to understand how they can still provide the essential features needed for organized and effective recruitment. Careful selection of a cheap ATS, supported by hands-on evaluation through free trials, allows you to confirm whether the system meets your operational needs before committing.

Assessing a Cheap ATS Before Committing

A free trial is your best way to vet a budget-friendly ATS. It’s an opportunity to look under the hood and see if the platform’s performance matches its promises. Use this practical checklist to make your evaluation period count.

• Identify Essentials: Does the system handle the absolute basics flawlessly? At a minimum, look for automated resume parsing that accurately extracts key information and a centralized dashboard for posting to multiple job boards. If these core functions are clumsy or inaccurate, the tool will create more work than it saves.
• Assess Customization: Can you tailor the system to your workflow? Check if you can edit job ad templates, customize email communications with candidates, and, most importantly, modify the stages in your hiring pipeline. A rigid system forces you to adapt your process to its limitations.
• User Experience (UX): Is the interface intuitive? During the trial, have a team member move a test candidate through the entire pipeline, from application to offer. If it requires manual or extensive training, it will hinder adoption and slow down your team.
• Hidden Limits: Scrutinize the plan for caps on the number of active job postings, user accounts, or candidates you can store. A low monthly fee becomes expensive quickly if you have to pay for overages or upgrade prematurely.
• Support: Don’t wait until you have a problem to test customer service. During your trial, ask a question through their support channel (live chat, email, or phone). Their response time and the quality of their answer will tell you everything you need to know about the support you’ll receive as a paying customer.

That said, Manatal’s applicant tracking system is known for providing functional features at a lower cost, with its Professional Plan priced at $15 per user per month (billed annually). In contrast, many enterprise-level systems are priced at $30 to $120 or more per user per month and often involve custom quotes and additional fees. Manatal's pricing model is transparent and straightforward. It includes features such as up to 10,000 candidates, the ability to collaborate with unlimited hiring managers, and up to 15 active job postings per account. This setup is particularly suitable for small businesses and recruitment agencies, providing essential capabilities without restrictive limitations, demonstrating that a budget-friendly ATS can be both practical and economical. Plus, Manatal offers a 14-day free trial with no credit card required, allowing for precisely this type of risk-free assessment.

{{cta}}

Building a Cost-Efficient Recruitment Stack

A truly savvy buyer knows that their cheap ATS is the central hub of a larger, cost-effective recruitment tech stack. Integrating powerful free and low-cost tools allows you to build an enterprise-grade ecosystem on a startup budget.

• Sourcing: Go beyond basic job board applications. Tools like Recruit’em help you build complex Boolean search strings for platforms like LinkedIn, while OctoHR is a Chrome extension designed for sourcing developer talent directly from GitHub.
• Job Posting: Increase your reach without increasing your ad spend. Niche and free job boards like Jora and Wellfound (formerly AngelList) offer excellent visibility, particularly for tech and startup roles.
• Screening: Use skills assessments to validate candidate abilities early on. Both HackerRank and TestGorilla offer robust free tiers that allow you to create and send technical or functional tests to applicants.
• Collaboration: Streamline internal and external communication. The free versions of Slack and Calendly are indispensable for quick team messaging and allowing candidates to self-schedule interviews, respectively.

The right ATS acts as the command center for these tools. Manatal, for instance, integrates seamlessly with platforms like Gmail and Outlook, and facilitates posting to 2,500+ job boards, centralizing your augmented ecosystem for maximum efficiency.

Budget Alternatives and Smart Buying Strategies

When a dedicated ATS isn't feasible, you can still manage your recruitment process using existing tools with a bit of creativity and effort. Here’s how you can craft a DIY system and find smart buying deals:

DIY System with Existing Tools:

• Use Gmail labels and filters for organizing candidate outreach.
• Create a visual candidate pipeline with Trello or Pipedrive boards.
• Set up a basic careers page using Wix or Carrd.

Smart Buying Strategies for Software:

• Explore software marketplaces like Vendr for negotiating better deals.
• Check review sites like G2 for exclusive discounts.
• Monitor deal sites like AppSumo and StackCommerce for lifetime deals on new recruitment software.

Evaluating Cheap ATS: A Smart Buyer's Framework

Beyond the trial, a comprehensive evaluation framework ensures you select a system that delivers long-term value. Focus on these critical areas.

• User Experience (UX) and Ease of Adoption for Recruiting Teams: An ATS should be intuitive and simple to use, minimizing training time and helping teams stay productive from day one.
• Support, Training, and Onboarding: What's Included?: Evaluate what support resources are included in the price, such as knowledge bases, tutorials, or onboarding sessions, to ensure the vendor actively supports your success.
• Data Security, Compliance, and Candidate Data Protection: Confirm the ATS meets standards like GDPR and CCPA, offering strong security measures and proper consent management to avoid costly compliance risks.

Ensuring Cost Efficiency

The advertised monthly fee is rarely the total cost of ownership. A savvy buyer learns to read between the lines and leverages smart tactics to maximize their return on investment.

• The Anatomy of a "Cheap" ATS Bill: Uncovering Potential Extras: Watch for hidden charges such as setup fees, premium job board costs, extra user seats, or paid API access; always request a full cost breakdown upfront.
• Smart Negotiation Tactics for Budget-Conscious Buyers: Negotiate for discounts by opting for annual contracts or asking vendors to waive fees or include extra licenses, especially near quarter-end.
• Leveraging Integrations and Clever Workarounds Effectively: Use integrations and external tools to avoid upgrade costs. For example, exporting data for reporting or connecting to free email solutions via Zapier.
• Optimizing Your Recruitment Process with a Lean System: Maximize ROI by ensuring full team adoption of core features such as tagging, templates, and pipeline management to streamline workflows and reduce bottlenecks.

Optimizing ATS Usage

Signing up is just the beginning. The real value is unlocked through consistent and strategic use of the platform over time.

• Effective User Adoption and Continuous Team Training: Ensure consistent usage by training your team on core workflows and establishing simple best-practice guidelines for tagging, naming, and pipeline management.
• Optimizing Your Recruitment Workflow and Leveraging Basic Analytics: Review foundational metrics like time-to-fill and source effectiveness to identify bottlenecks and improve the hiring process through data-driven decisions.
• Enhancing Candidate Experience, Even with Limited Features: Use built-in automation and polished email templates to provide timely updates and consistent communication, creating a professional and positive candidate experience.
• Building Talent Pools and Nurturing Candidate Relationships on a Budget: Tag and organize strong but unsuccessful candidates into searchable groups, allowing you to re-engage qualified talent for future roles without additional sourcing costs.

Conclusion

Choosing a budget-friendly Applicant Tracking System (ATS) is crucial for efficiency without overspending. The market offers affordable tools that streamline recruitment and enhance candidate experiences. Focus on three key strategies: use free trials to evaluate options, prioritize features that solve your main issues, and ensure clear pricing to avoid hidden fees. A suitable ATS will make your recruitment team more strategic and efficient, essential for small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), which have adoption rates around 20-35% according to recent reports.[1] Start by identifying essential features, shortlisting budget options, and leveraging free trials to find the best fit for your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How to compare pricing models of cheap ATS platforms?

A: To compare affordable Applicant Tracking System (ATS) platforms, evaluate the pricing model, whether it's subscription-based, per-user, or per-job, and consider potential hidden fees for features. Assess the pricing's scalability and flexibility to ensure it accommodates growth without unexpected costs. Balance the cost against feature value and improvements in recruitment efficiency, as time saved can justify a higher price. Thorough analysis helps businesses find the best value ATS for their needs.

Q: Which core features matter most for small recruitment teams?

A: For small recruitment teams, the key features are automation, candidate relationship management, and collaboration tools. Automation streamlines tasks like interview scheduling and resume screening, allowing the team to focus on strategic recruitment activities. Candidate relationship management helps maintain applicant data and communication history, while collaboration tools enable real-time sharing of notes and feedback. Together, these features boost productivity, speed up hiring, and enhance the candidate experience, leading to more successful hires.

Q: How to evaluate data security in cheap ATS solutions?

A: Evaluating data security in affordable ATS solutions involves examining encryption standards, regulatory compliance, user access controls, and data storage practices. It's essential to ensure SSL/TLS is used, data is encrypted at rest, and measures like two-factor authentication are in place. Verifying regular security audits, a strong security track record, and consulting user reviews can also provide insights into the ATS’s security reliability.

Q: What are the trade-offs between premium and cheap ATS plans?

A: When choosing between premium and cheap Applicant Tracking System (ATS) plans, organizations face trade-offs. Premium plans offer advanced features like sophisticated analytics, integration with other HR tools, and superior support, benefiting larger organizations with substantial hiring needs. However, they are more costly. In contrast, cheaper plans provide basic recruitment tools at lower costs, ideal for smaller companies or startups, though they may lack scalability as the organization grows. The decision depends on the company's size, budget, and specific recruitment needs.

Q: How to calculate the total cost of ownership for an ATS?

A: To determine the total cost of ownership (TCO) for an Applicant Tracking System (ATS), it's essential to evaluate both direct and indirect costs throughout its lifecycle. Direct costs comprise software fees, implementation, and hardware needs, while indirect costs include IT support, maintenance, training, and potential downtime during the transition. Also, consider scalability and integration with other systems for long-term costs. Adding these factors provides a complete picture of the ATS's TCO, aiding in budget and financial planning.

—

Citation

1. Select Software Reviews